Which Planet Are They On? Bernard Davies responds to Positive for Youth's Progress!?



Positive for Youth, the Government’s long-trailed youth strategy document was finally released in December 2011. After much early hype, it quickly fell below, if not actually off, the DfE radar – a reflection, no doubt, of Michael Gove’s openly declared determination to get youth policy out of his department altogether. With this now off-loaded onto the Cabinet Office, closure for the DfE was achieved a couple of weeks ago with the release of a Positive for Youth ‘progress’ report.

After I’d ploughed through its thirty five pages of self-congratulatory text, boxed case studies overflowing with unproblematic success stories and disingenuous tables of figures, I emerged asking myself: On what planet have Coalition ministers been living for the last three years? Where does the world-in-crisis I now inhabit fit with their view of a youth generation whose ‘sense of well being’ in that time has been on the up and up and may now even be at some kind of peak?

More specifically:

  • Where in this society are the one million young people who have been unemployed for months?

  • Or, with rough sleeping in London alone up by 13%, the 770,000 young people who each year seek help because they are homeless?

  • With a 170% rise in the use of food banks, where are the young people whose families are so poor they can’t feed them properly – or at all?

  • Or those three young men who every day are at risk of taking their own lives?

  • Or the disabled young people whose means of support have been taken away by the Government’s so-called welfare reforms?

  • Or those thousands of young people who relied on the Educational Maintenance Allowance to get them to college each day?

And, amid all the paper’s euphoria about young people who are being consulted on what services they want, influencing policies and deciding how money should be spent, who were the youth ‘representatives’ who told the Government:

  • to cut Youth Services by on average 28% between 2010 and 2012;

  • to impose more than 50% cuts on those Services in nineteen English counties, rising elsewhere to 70, 80 or even 100%; and

  • to remove an average of 9.6 local authority youth work posts during 2011-12 and a further 6.8 in the first half of 2012-13?

And how does the Government reconcile its glib assertion that local authorities are now entirely free to decide for themselves what youth services to provide with its four-year, 27% cut in funding for local councils?

Back on austerity earth, thousands of emotional miles, it seems, from the universe which our current ministers inhabit, the perspective becomes sharper. This so-called ‘progress report’ is way beyond disingenuous. It is deeply dishonest.

Bernard Davies

July 2013

If you’ve got a strong stomach the Progress Report is to be found here.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.